Birnbaum’s examples add an important aspect to the story that make the essay more convincing. He started to take advantage of his wheelchair and began to expect special treatment. Some people that I have talked to about how the wheel chair changed their life have different responses. It is a respectful thing in our society to give disabled people the privileges they deserve, as long as the privileges are not taken advantage of in a selfish manner. We are really sorry but we cannot send the sample immediately. It seems we are all in conclusion that his personal stories helped make his story more convincing. How about getting this access immediately?

He realizes that even if he has lost his legs, there are new opportunities, although considered minor or insignificant to others, which he now begins to enjoy because of his inability to walk. If someone who was not handicapped said that handicapped people could sneak Cuban cigars in a portable shower seat through Customs, we probably wouldn’t believe them. I can see your point of view as well, though. Don’t get me wrong i do feel like they are at a disadvantage and I feel sorry for them when I see them wheeling themselves around. Then after he became disabled, he realized the way that special treatment affected him as well as others.

As bad as it sounds, I feel like he in somewhat making his disability humorous. People who are disabled can understand this difference easier than those looking from the outside in.

Exploiting The Catbird Seat Essay Sample

I do believe that there are many disabled people in wheelchair who do not get the same treatment. I think that Caleb brings davidd many valid points, and proves that the examples are relevant to the story. Please choose the access option you need: Now do some people in wheelchairs take advantage like in the story?

David Birnbaum’s personal experiences makes his essay, “The Catbird Seat”, even more convincing because it holds true and provides evidence by supplying examples. I agree with you that disabled people understand the hierarchy more than people on the outside.


Rather than just generalizing, he actually provides examples as to why he thinks birrnbaum way he does, which birnnaum us to understand how he learns the pecking order of those who are disabled, or simply “different”, from everyone else. While his own examples makes his personal experiences seem reliable, there may be other people in the world who have not had the same experience.

By saying that he virnbaum by with a lot of things shows how much the disability affects his life.

February 11, “The Catbird Seat” by David Birnbaum – Mrs. Weber’s English

College Composition I English 2: He also shows from his point of view the different levels of disability and what that meant to him, knowing that there was a disability that was considered worse than his. He lived this story and so their isn’t much way to argue against it. Walking, running, and jumping are all some of the things that everyday people take for granted. We will write a custom essay sample on The Catbird Seat specifically for you.

The Catbird Seat

Using our plagiarism checker for free you will receive the requested result within 3 hours directly to your email Jump the queue with a membership plan, get unlimited samples and plagiarism results — immediately! Although from giving us his experience it makes us realize how they all get treated different whether they like it or not. Reprimand — A rebuke, esp. Kallie, I love that you saw the humor in his essay.

the catbird seat david birnbaum thesis

All we see are his experiences and it can shadow others outlook on being in a wheel chair. By adding this detail he conveys that he is no different from other people. Or if you need this sample for free, we can send it to you via email.


In this story he gives thesus details of stories within the story of how he may have abused the privileges of being disabled and how he took advantage of these privileges. I found your perspective very similiar to that of everyones else. Would you like to get such a paper? I do believe that society does let people with disabilities have privileges such as cutting in line like he said.

I really thought you got your point across.

the catbird seat david birnbaum thesis

He snuck in Cuban cigars. This is not to say that people should stop treating the disabled specially, but that we should rethink our views on how we perceive people with disability, the aged, and the pregnant, and give them more dignity and less pity — after all, they are not always helpless as they seem.

Exploiting The Catbird Seat | Essay Example

I think the pregnant woman spoke up to him because she was pregnant and thought that she was more important because of that. He showed me that the handicapped are more privileged than we think they are. Although Birnbaum does not explicitly express it, his essay reveals that there is more to those who have birrnbaum disability than what meets the eye; they are not as helpless as we often imagine them to be.

He went ahead with his life caring little what other people actually thought of him. I think that all of Birnbaum’s personal experiences helps the story along.

Someone might say that his personal examples make his story more subjective and, therefore, less credible.